Finance and Society, 5(1): 61-83. https://doi.org/10.2218/finsoc.v5i1.3018

This article draws on and extends Viviana Zelizer’s social meaning of money framework in conjunction with new work in ‘relational accounting’ to suggest a sociological counterpoint, focusing in particular on the social and symbolic meaning attached to individual 401(k) retirement accounts. Following a market downturn, neoclassical and behavioral economics predict various types of behavioral responses, in particular loss aversion – where investors seek to increase risk-taking rather than locking in a sure loss (a loss is more painful to bear than an equivalent gain). A sociological theory that understands the shared meaning of retirement saving would predict something different, a behavior I call durable conservatism. In this article, I show how this concept better explains observed risk behavior in Americans’ 401(k) accounts following the 2002 and 2008 bear markets in stocks, and how that response differed from the behavior documented in non-retirement brokerage accounts.

Keywords: Economic sociology, relational accounting, retirement, financial risk, behavioral economics

Methods: interrupted time series analysis (ITSA); differences-in-differences regression

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *